Guide for online store owners

How to handle e-commerce returns and RMAs: a step-by-step process

I deal with returns and RMAs every working day for a UK-based online store. This is the process I follow, written down so you can use it in your own shop.

By MD Elias Hossain7 min readUpdated 30 October 2026

Nobody starts an online store because they love processing returns. But the way you handle them matters more than most owners think. A customer who gets a quick, fair answer about a faulty item will often buy from you again. One who has to chase you three times usually won’t.

You don’t need expensive software to do this well. A clear policy, one place to keep track of every case and regular updates to the customer will cover most of it. Here’s how I’d set it up.

1. Start with a policy people can actually follow

If your returns page is vague, you’ll spend your week explaining it. Before anything else, check that it answers these questions in plain words:

  • How many days after delivery can someone ask for a return?
  • What condition does the item need to be in?
  • Who pays for return postage, and does that change if the item is faulty?
  • What does the customer get back: a refund, a replacement, store credit or a repair?
  • Which products can’t be returned, for example made-to-order or already-installed items?

Then link to it from your order confirmation emails. It sounds obvious, but plenty of stores forget, and customers can’t follow a policy they’ve never seen.

2. Keep every request in one place

It doesn’t matter much whether that’s a spreadsheet, a help desk or the order notes in WooCommerce. What matters is that every case has the same basic details (order number, product, reason, photos, date opened and current status) and that anyone on your team can open it and see where things stand without asking around.

3. Check the request before you send any instructions

This is the step people skip when they’re busy. Before you send a returns label, read the request against your policy. Is it still within the window? Do the photos show a real fault, or has the customer simply changed their mind? Can this product be returned at all? Five minutes here can save you paying for a return you never needed to accept.

Tip: ask for photos of the item, the box and any serial number right at the start. If the case turns into a warranty claim later, the manufacturer will almost certainly want them, and it’s much easier to ask once than twice.

4. Give it an RMA number and clear instructions

The RMA (return merchandise authorisation) number is what connects the parcel that turns up at your warehouse to the right order. Send everything the customer needs in one message, not three:

  • the RMA number, and where to write it on the parcel
  • the return address, plus the label if you’re providing one
  • how to pack the item so it doesn’t get damaged on the way back
  • what happens next, and roughly how long it takes

Note the RMA number on the order too, so you can find it later.

5. Look at the item properly when it arrives

Keep an eye on the tracking, and when the parcel lands, actually check it. Is it the right product? Is everything there? Does the problem match what the customer described? Write down what you found before you decide anything.

6. Decide what happens next

Most cases end in one of four ways. Change-of-mind returns inside the policy get a refund. Items that arrived damaged or wrong get a replacement. Sometimes a repair is quicker and cheaper for everyone. And if a product failed after normal use, it becomes a warranty claim with the manufacturer.

A return isn’t the same as a warranty claim

These get mixed up a lot. A return is between you and your customer. A warranty claim involves the manufacturer, and they’ll usually want proof of purchase, photos, a serial number and a clear description of the fault. In my experience, warranty claims are the cases most likely to get stuck, simply because everyone assumes someone else is chasing them. Give each claim one owner who follows it up and keeps the customer posted until it’s sorted.

7. Record it properly in your store

If you’re on WooCommerce or Shopify, refund against the original order rather than sending the money another way. Your reports stay accurate, and the next person who opens that order can see exactly what happened. While you’re there, add a short note: what came back, why, and what you decided. If you sent a replacement, link the new order to the old one.

8. Keep the customer in the loop

A lot of “where’s my refund?” emails could have been avoided with a two-line update. I send one when the RMA is issued, another when the parcel arrives, and a last one when the refund or replacement goes out. Each takes a minute, and it saves a lot of back-and-forth.

Mistakes I see a lot

  • Sending a returns label before checking whether the request fits the policy.
  • Refunding before the item has come back and been checked.
  • Handling returns in someone’s personal inbox, where nobody else can see them.
  • Going quiet on the customer while you wait to hear from a supplier.

Look back once a month

Every few weeks, read through the reasons people gave for sending things back. If one product keeps returning for the same reason, it’s usually telling you something: the description isn’t clear, the photos are misleading, or there’s a quality problem worth raising with the supplier. Your returns log is honest feedback you’re already collecting, so it’s worth using.

Rather not deal with this yourself?

Returns, RMAs and warranty claims are a big part of my day job. I can do the same for your store and keep your customers in the loop until every case is closed.

See how I manage returns and RMAs

Ready to hand over the inbox?

Tell me about your store and the help you need. I usually reply within 24 hours.

Message Hire me on Upwork